Specialist Forum

Rethink, derivation and review on the starting pressure gradient and pressure sensitivity effect

  • Yuanqian Chen ,
  • Pan Liu ,
  • Danfeng Lei
Expand
  • 1. Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration and Development, PetroChina, Beijing 100083
    2. China University of Geosciences(Beijing), Energy College, Beijing 100083

Received date: 2020-12-10

  Online published: 2021-02-04

Abstract

The starting pressure gradient and pressure sensitivity effect proposed by Bear(1972) and Fatt(1952) respectively have practical significance for the development of low permeability oil and gas reservoirs. The so-called starting pressure gradient refers to the critical pressure gradient that causes the oil and gas formations to start flowing. The so-called pressure-sensitive effect includes the phenomenon that the formation permeability decreases as the formation pressure drops. Due to the theoretical needs of tight and low-permeability reservoir development analysis in the Ordos Basin, relevant experts and scholars in China have paid attention to the starting pressure gradient and pressure sensitivity effect for nearly 20 years, but their understanding is still in the initial perceptual stage. The reason is the lack of basic derivation. The derivation in this paper shows that the pressure gradient and starting pressure gradient of Darcy linear flow are constant, but the pressure gradient and starting pressure gradient of Darcy plane radial flow both are functions of radial radius. It is incorrect to directly apply the constant starting pressure gradient of linear flow to the plane radial flow equation. Although the pressure sensitivity effect of permeability exists, it can never be used in the flow equation of Darcy’s law. Because constant permeability is the basis for the establishment of Darcy’s law. Otherwise, it will shake the theoretical foundations of Ground Fluid Dynamics, Petroleum Reservoir Engineering and Reservoir Numerical Simulation.

Cite this article

Yuanqian Chen , Pan Liu , Danfeng Lei . Rethink, derivation and review on the starting pressure gradient and pressure sensitivity effect[J]. Petroleum Reservoir Evaluation and Development, 2021 , 11(1) : 7 -13 . DOI: 10.13809/j.cnki.cn32-1825/te.2021.01.002

References

[1] Bear, J.: Dynamic of fluid in porous media, American Elsevier Publishing Company, Inc., 1972, 127-128.
[2] Fatt, I., Davis, T.S.: Reduced in permeability with overburden pressure, Petroleum Trans. AIME, 1952,195, 329.
[3] 黄雨, 李晓平, 谭晓华, 等: 考虑启动压力梯度的复合气藏不稳定压力动态分析, 新疆石油地质, 2019,40(2) 235-243.
[3] Huang Yu, Li Xiaoping, Tan Xiaohua, et al: Dynamic analysis on unsteady pressure of composite gas reservoirs with consideration of threshold pressure gradient, Xinjiang Petroleum Geology, 2019,40(2) 235-243.
[4] 王晓冬, 侯晓春, 郝明强, 等: 低渗透介质有启动压力梯度的不稳态压力分析, 石油学报 2011,32(5) 847-851.
[4] Wang Xiaodong, Hou Xiaochun, Hao Mingqiang, et al: Pressure transient analysis in low-permeable media with threshold gradients, Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2011,32(5), 847-851.
[5] 汪全林, 唐海, 吕栋梁, 等: 低渗透油藏启动压力梯度实验研究, 油气地质与采收率, 2011,18(1) 97-100.
[5] Wang Quanlin, Tang Hai, Lü Dongliang, et al: An experimental study on threshold pressure gradient in low permeability reservoir, Petroleum Geology and Recovery Efficiency, 2011,18(1), 97-100.
[6] 许家峰, 孙福街, 田冀, 等: 考虑启动压力梯度时普通稠油非线性渗流模型解析求解方法, 中国海上油气, 2011,23(1) 32-35.
[6] Xu Jiafeng, Sun Fujie, Tian Ji, et al: An analytic solution method of nonlinear seepage models with ordinary heavy oil when taking threshold pressure gradient into consideration, China Offshore Oil and Gas, 2011,23(1) 32-35.
[7] 蒋裕强, 高阳, 徐厚伟, 等: 基于启动压力梯度的亲水低渗透储层物性下限确定方法——以蜀南河包场地区须家河组气藏为例, 油气地质与采收率, 2010,17(5) 57-60.
[7] Jiang Yujiang, Gao Yang, Xu Houwei, et al: New method for determining cut-off parameter in hydrophilic and low permeable sandstone reservoir-case of gas reservoir in Hebaochang area, Petroleum Geology and Recovery Efficiency, 2010,17(5) 57-60.
[8] 高海红, 程林松, 冯儒勇: 考虑启动压力梯度的低渗气藏水平井产能计算, 天然气工业, 2008,28(7) 75-77.
[8] Gao Haihong, Cheng Linsong, Feng Ruyong: Productivity calculation of horizontal wells in low-permeability gas reservoirs considering starting pressure gradient, Natural Gas Industry, 2008,28(7) 75-77.
[9] 李浩, 赵鹏大, 刘柏林: 拟启动压力对低渗透单相流体及油水两相渗流的影响—以沙埝油田沙7断块为例, 油气地质与采收率, 2008,15(1) 84-86.
[9] Li Hao, Zhao Pengda, Liu Bolin: Effects of starting pressure on single phase fluid and oil/water two-phase fluid flow in low permeability reservoir-case study in Sha 7 fault block in Shanian Oilfield, Petroleum Geology and Recovery Efficiency, 2008,15(1) 84-86.
[10] 李爱芬, 张少辉, 刘敏, 等: 一种测定低渗油藏启动压力的新方法, 中国石油大学学报(自然科学版), 2008,32(1) 68-71.
[10] Li Aifen, Zhang Shaohui, Liu Min, et al: A new method of measuring starting pressure for low permeability reservoir, Journal of China University of Petroleum(Edition of Natural Science), 2008,32(1) 68-71.
[11] 郭肖, 伍勇: 启动压力梯度和应力敏感效应对低渗透气藏水平井产能的影响, 石油与天然气地质, 2007,28(4) 539-543.
[11] Guo Xiao, Wu Yong: Influence of start-up pressure gradient and stress sensitivity on productivity of low-permeability gas reservoirs, Oil & Gas Geology, 2007,28(4) 539-543.
[12] 何贤科: 确定低渗透储层启动压力梯度的新方法, 石油地质与工程, 2007,21(5) 80-84.
[12] He Xianke: A new method of determining the starting pressure gradient in low permeability reservoirs, Petroleum Geology and Engineering, 2007,21(5) 80-84.
[13] 郝明强, 杨正明, 刘学伟, 等: 裂缝性低渗透油藏压力敏感性研究, 新疆石油地质, 2006,27(4) 471-473.
[13] Hao Mingqiang, Yang Zhengming, Liu Xuewei, et al: A study on pressure sensitivity of fractured low-permeability reservoirs, Xinjiang Petroleum Geology, 2006,27(4) 471-473.
[14] 赵国忠: 变启动压力梯度三维三相渗流数值模拟方法, 石油学报, 2006,27(S1) 119-128.
[14] Zhao Guozhong: Numerical simulation of 3D and three-phase flow with variable start-up pressure gradient, Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2006,27(S1) 119-128.
[15] 罗瑞兰, 程林松, 彭建春, 等: 油气储层渗透率应力敏感性与启动压力梯度的关系, 西南石油学院学报, 2005,27(3) 20-22.
[15] Luo Ruilan, Cheng Linsong, Peng Jianchun, et al: The relationship between stress-sensitivity permeability and starting pressure gradient of reservoir, Journal of Southwestern Petroleum Institute, 2005,27(3) 20-22.
[16] 韩洪宝, 程林松, 张明禄, 等: 特低渗油藏考虑启动压力梯度的物理模拟及数值模拟方法, 石油大学学报(自然科学版), 2004,28(6) 49-53.
[16] Han Hongbao, Cheng Linsong, Zhang Minglu, et al: Physical simulation of ultra-low permeability reservoir in consideration of starting pressure gradient, Journal of China University of Petroleum, 2004,28(6) 49-53.
[17] 阮敏, 王连刚: 低渗透油田开发与压敏效应, 石油学报, 2002,23(3) 73-76.
[17] Ruan Min, Wang Liangang: Low-permeability oilfield development and pressure-sensitive effect, Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2002,23(3) 73-76.
[18] 阮敏: 压敏效应对低渗透油田开发的影响, 西安石油学院学报(自然科学版), 2001,16(4) 40-41.
[18] Ruan Min: Effect of pressure-sensitive damage on the development of low permeability reservoirs, Journal of Xi’an Petroleum Institute(Natural Science Edition), 2001,16(4) 40-41.
[19] 孙龙德, 宋文杰, 江同文: 克拉2气田储层应力敏感性及对产能影响的实验研究, 中国科学(D辑:地球科学), 2004,34(S1) 134-142.
[20] 李治平, 万怡妏, 张喜亭: 低渗透气藏气井产能评价新方法, 天然气工业, 2007,27(4) 85-87.
[20] Li Zhiping, Wan Yiwen, Zhang Xiting: A new method for deliverability analysis of gas wells in low-permeability reservoirs, Natural Gas Industry, 2007,27(4) 85-87.
[21] 何军, 胡永乐, 何东博, 等: 低渗致密气藏产能预测方法, 断块油气田, 2013,20(3) 334-336.
[21] He Jun, Hu Yongle, He Dongbo, et al: Productivity prediction methods for tight gas reservoir with low permeability, Fault-Block Oil & Gas Field, 2013,20(3) 334-336.
[22] 姜瑞忠, 李林凯, 徐建春, 等: 低渗透油藏非线性渗流新模型及试井分析, 石油学报, 2012,33(2) 264-268.
[22] Jiang Ruizhong, Li Linkai, Xu Jianchun, et al: A nonlinear mathematical model for low-permeability reservoirs and well-testing analysis, Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2012,33(2) 264-268.
[23] 杨仁锋, 姜瑞忠, 刘世华: 低渗透油藏考虑非线性渗流的必要性论证, 断块油气田, 2011,18(4) 493-497.
[23] Yang Renfeng, Jiang Ruizhong, Liu Shihua: Demonstration of essentiality of considering nonlinear flow in low permeability reservoir, Fault-Block Oil & Gas Field, 2011,18(4) 493-497.
[24] 闫栋栋, 杨满平, 田乃林, 等: 低流度油藏渗流特征研究——以中国中东部某油田低流度油藏为例, 油气地质与采收率, 2010,17(6) 90-93.
[24] Yan Dongdong, Yang Manping, Tian Nailin, et al: Fluid mechanics study on low fluidity reservoir-case study of one low fluidity reservoir in central and east China, Petroleum Geology and Recovery Efficiency, 2010,17(6) 90-93.
[25] 宋传真, 郑荣臣: 致密低渗气藏储层应力敏感性及其对单井产能的影响, 大庆石油地质与开发, 2006,25(6) 47-49.
[25] Song Chuanzhen, Zheng Rongchen: Stress sensitivity of low-permeability tight gas reservoir and its effect on single well productivity, Petroleum Geology & Oilfield Development in Daqing, 2006,25(6) 47-49.
[26] 李凡华, 刘慈群: 含启动压力梯度的不定常渗流压力动态分析, 油气井测试, 1997,6(1) 1-4.
[26] Li Fanhua, Liu Ciqun: Pressure transient analysis for unsteady porous flow with start-up pressure derivative, Well Testing, 1997,6(1) 1-4.
[27] 王恩志, 韩小妹, 黄远智: 低渗岩石非线性渗流机理讨论, 岩土力学, 2003,24(S2) 120-124.
[27] Wang Enzhi, Han Xiaomei, Huang Yuanzhi: Discussion on the mechanism of percolation in low permeability rocks, Rock and Soil Mechanics, 2003,24(S2) 120-124.
[28] 郑维师, 刘易非: 低渗砂岩气藏中压敏效应对产能的影响, 天然气工业, 2004,24(12) 113-115.
[28] Zheng Weishi, Liu Yifei: Influence of pressure-sensitive effect on productivity of low permeable sand gas reservoirs, Natural Gas Industry, 2004,24(12) 113-115.
[29] 姜汉桥, 姚军, 姜瑞忠: 油藏工程原理与方法, 东营: 石油大学出版社, 2001, 37-40.
[30] 苏玉亮, 蔡明玉, 孟凡坤, 等: 低渗透油藏CO2驱试井解释方法, 油气地质与采收率, 2020,27(1) 113-119.
[30] Su Yuliang, Cai Mingyu, Meng Fankun, et al: Well testing interpretation method for CO2 flooding in low permeability oil reservoirs, Petroleum Geology and Recovery Efficiency, 2020,27(1) 113-119.
[31] 姜汉桥, 赵玉云, 陈强, 等: 致密油藏水平井压裂裂缝参数优化方法, 中国海上油气, 2020,32(3) 77-85.
[31] Jiang Hanqiao, Zhao Yuyun, Chen Qiang, et al: Optimal method of fracture parameters for horizontal well fracturing in tight oil reservoir, China Offshore Oil and Gas, 2020,32(3) 77-85.
[32] 张景, 王颖, 范希彬, 等: 致密砂砾岩储层应力敏感性评价研究, 中国海上油气, 2020,32(3) 105-110.
[32] Zhang Jing, Wang Ying, Fan Xibin, et al: Evaluation study on the stress sensitivity of tight glutenite reservoir, China Offshore Oil and Gas, 2020,32(3) 105-110.
[33] Cornell, D., Donald, L., Katz, D.L.: Flow of gases through porous media, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry, 1953,45(10) 2145-2152.
[34] Green L., Duwez, P.: Fluid flow through porous media, Journal of Applied Mechanics, 1951,18(1) 39-45.
[35] 陈元千: 现代油藏工程(第2版), 石油工业出版社, 北京, 2020, 11-16.
[35] Chen Yuanqian.: Modern petroleum reservoir engineering(Second Edition), Petroleum Industry Press, Beijing, 2020, 11-16.
[36] 陈元千, 邹存友, 杨皓, 等: 利用气井测试资料建立湍流系数的新公式, 断块油气田, 2010,17(3) 320-324.
[36] Chen Yuanqian, Zou Cunyou, Yang Hao, et al: A new formula for establishing turbulence coefficient from testing data of gas wells, Fault-Block Oil & Gas Field, 2010,17(3) 320-324.
[37] 陈元千: 线性流的启动压力梯度不能用于平面径向流方程, 石油学报, 2011,32(6) 1088-1092.
[37] Chen Yuanqian.: Improper use of the starting pressure gradient of linear flow in the plane radial flow equation, Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2011,32(6) 1088-1092.
Outlines

/